Employee Actions Off The Clock

In case you missed it, Joseph Andolino, a senior vice president of Halliburton's tax department was arrested in a Harris County prostitution sting along with six other men (reported in the Houston Business Journal).  While there are no reports that he committed the crime on the job, several questions relating to his on-going employment with Halliburton come up.   

 

While I don't think that employers want to overly intrude into the private lives of employees, as an employer do you  have a policy or an employment contract that says an employee may be terminated if s/he engages in criminal conduct?  Do any of your company policies address employees conviction of a crime that indicates unfitness for the job or raises a threat to the safety or well being of fellow employees? 

Texas is an at-will state.  That allows Texas employers a lot of latitude in the hiring and firing decisions.  Essentially an employer can terminate an employee for any reason that is not specifically prohibited by law.  However, state legislation, employment contracts, union contracts or your internal policies may dictate your decision.   An employment clause may provide you with an avenue for dismissal.  But does it mandate the dismissal?

• Do you have to prove that the conduct has a direct impact on the job? 
• Does it compromise the employee's ability to do the job? 
• It is an embarrassment to the organization? 

We all agree that an employer shouldn't keep an employee whose after-work activities affect their job performance.  The general rule is the more off-duty behavior negatively affects the work environment, the more termination and/or discipline becomes a legal and valid option.  But, is failure to take remedial action regarding the off-duty conduct inferring that similar actions are condoned on the job?

 

Companies may face difficulty when dealing with terminating employees for off-duty conduct. Potential results when employee's are fired for off-duty behavior can be negative publicity, low morale and related turnover.   You must consider the nature of the crime and how it affects the workplace.  What effect, if any, does the behavior have to the workplace or the company's image?   Does the behavior justify adverse employment action?

 

If you are considering regulating the off-duty conduct of your employees, there are some things to be considered:

• Is the conduct legal or illegal?
• Is there an applicable law that protects the off-duty conduct of the employee?
• Am I willing to apply this policy consistently?

Jason Bosch, None Of Your Business (Interest):  The Argument for Protecting All Employee Behavior With NO Business Impact: " . . . employees should not have to relinquish autonomy over very aspect of their lives just to get or keep a job.   Employers have a vested interest in controlling those aspects of employee's lives that reasonably affect the employees' performance on the job, but that does not justify giving employers carte blanche to control every aspect of their employees' lives."